Can You Mix Biodiesel With Regular Diesel? (Its Effect on the Engine)

By /
Can You Mix Biodiesel With Regular Diesel?

Yes, you can mix biodiesel with regular diesel. Biodiesel and diesel can be blended in any ratio, as biodiesel is essentially compatible with diesel. Common blend ratios include B5 (5% biodiesel, 95% diesel), B20 (20% biodiesel, 80% diesel), and B100 (100% biodiesel).

The exact ratio you choose can depend on several factors:

  1. Engine Compatibility: Older diesel engines might not be compatible with high biodiesel blends. Check the manufacturer’s recommendations.
  2. Temperature: Biodiesel can gel at lower temperatures than regular diesel. In colder climates, lower blends like B5 or B10 are often used.
  3. Emission Reduction Goals: Higher biodiesel blends can reduce emissions more effectively, but may also reduce engine performance slightly.
  4. Fuel Availability and Cost: Biodiesel’s availability and cost vary by region.
  5. Storage and Handling: Biodiesel can be more prone to water absorption and microbial growth. Proper storage and handling are necessary, especially for higher blends.

It’s important to ensure that the biodiesel used meets quality standards like ASTM D6751 in the USA or EN 14214 in Europe to avoid potential engine problems. Regular maintenance and monitoring of fuel filters and engine performance are also advisable when using biodiesel blends.

Read related article: What is the Difference Between Red and Green Diesel?

Chemical Compatibility of Biodiesel and Diesel

Chemical Structure

  1. Biodiesel Structure:
    • Biodiesel is primarily composed of long-chain fatty acid esters, typically methyl or ethyl esters.
    • These molecules are produced by transesterification, a chemical process where triglycerides (from vegetable oils or animal fats) react with an alcohol (usually methanol or ethanol).
    • The typical molecular structure of biodiesel includes a glycerol backbone attached to three fatty acid chains, which are then converted into fatty acid methyl esters (FAME) or fatty acid ethyl esters (FAEE).
  2. Diesel Structure:
    • Regular diesel is a complex mixture of hydrocarbons, primarily alkanes, cycloalkanes, and aromatic hydrocarbons.
    • These hydrocarbons generally range from C10 to C22 (10 to 22 carbon atoms per molecule) in diesel fuel.
    • The structure and composition of diesel can vary significantly depending on the source of the crude oil and the refining process.

Solubility and Miscibility

  1. Solubility:
    • Biodiesel and diesel are both non-polar liquids, making them mutually soluble.
    • The ester functional groups in biodiesel can interact with the hydrocarbon chains in diesel, allowing for a homogeneous mixture at any proportion.
  2. Miscibility:
    • Biodiesel and diesel are completely miscible in all proportions. This means they can be mixed in any ratio without phase separation under normal conditions.
    • However, the presence of contaminants or extreme temperatures can affect this miscibility. For example, high levels of water or impurities can lead to phase separation.
  3. Effect of Fatty Acid Composition:
    • The specific fatty acid composition of biodiesel can influence its solubility and stability in diesel.
    • Saturated fatty acids (with no double bonds) tend to increase the cloud point (the temperature at which crystals start forming), affecting cold weather performance.
    • Unsaturated fatty acids (with one or more double bonds) improve cold flow properties but can be more prone to oxidation.
  4. Temperature Considerations:
    • At low temperatures, biodiesel has a higher tendency to gel compared to regular diesel.
    • This gelling can cause issues in fuel filters and lines, especially in blends with high biodiesel content.
    • The use of cold flow improvers and blending with winter-grade diesel can mitigate these issues.
  5. Storage and Stability:
    • Biodiesel blends can be more susceptible to oxidation and degradation over time compared to pure diesel.
    • The presence of biodiesel can accelerate the formation of gums and sediments if stored for long periods, especially in the presence of oxygen and at higher temperatures.

While biodiesel and diesel are chemically compatible and can be mixed in any ratio, factors like the fatty acid composition of the biodiesel, temperature conditions, and storage stability need to be considered to ensure optimal performance and longevity of the fuel blend.

Read related article: How to Increase Diesel Fuel Cetane? (5 Effective Methods)

Effects of Biodiesel Blends on Engine Performance

Biodiesel blends are often categorized by their biodiesel content: B5 (5% biodiesel, 95% diesel), B20 (20% biodiesel, 80% diesel), and B100 (100% biodiesel). The effects of these blends on engine performance vary, influenced by the biodiesel’s properties and the engine’s design and condition.

Engine Efficiency and Power Output

  1. B5 Blend:
    • Efficiency: B5 blends generally have a negligible impact on engine efficiency. The energy content of B5 is slightly lower than pure diesel (by approximately 1-2%), but this difference is often imperceptible in terms of performance.
    • Power Output: There is typically no noticeable change in power output with B5 blends. The lubricating properties of biodiesel can even benefit engine operation by reducing wear.
  2. B20 Blend:
    • Efficiency: With B20, a slight decrease in fuel economy (around 2-3%) is observed due to the lower energy content of biodiesel compared to diesel (about 8-12% lower on a volumetric basis).
    • Power Output: A marginal decrease in power and torque might be observed with B20, but this is usually within the normal operational variability of the engine.
  3. B100 Blend:
    • Efficiency: B100 has a significant reduction in energy content (8-12% less than diesel), which can lead to a noticeable decrease in fuel economy (up to 10-12%).
    • Power Output: Engines running on B100 may experience a reduction in power output and torque due to the lower calorific value of biodiesel. However, modern engines designed or adapted for B100 can mitigate these effects.

Case Studies and Research Findings

  1. Heavy-Duty Vehicles:
    • A study showed that heavy-duty trucks using B20 had a 1-2% decrease in fuel economy compared to those using regular diesel. However, emissions of particulate matter and hydrocarbons were significantly lower.
    • Another research on long-haul trucks indicated a minimal impact on engine wear and maintenance when switching from diesel to B20.
  2. Passenger Vehicles:
    • Research involving passenger cars showed a negligible impact on engine performance and fuel economy with B5 and B10 blends.
    • With B100, some older engines exhibited issues with fuel filters and seals, due to the solvent properties of biodiesel.
  3. Agricultural Equipment:
    • Studies on tractors and other farming equipment found that B20 blends performed comparably to diesel in terms of power output, with some benefits in engine lubrication and reduced emissions.

Lower biodiesel blends like B5 and B20 have minimal impact on engine performance and efficiency, making them suitable for most diesel engines without modifications. B100, while offering environmental benefits, may require engine modifications and careful consideration of fuel handling and storage. The choice of blend should be based on the specific requirements and compatibility of the engine, as well as the desired balance between performance, environmental impact, and fuel availability.

Impact on Fuel System and Engine Components

Interaction with Fuel System Materials

  1. Rubber Components:
    • Biodiesel has a higher solvency than diesel, which can lead to the degradation of certain rubber materials used in hoses, gaskets, and seals.
    • Natural rubber and nitrile rubber components can swell, soften, or degrade when exposed to biodiesel, especially at concentrations above B20.
    • For B100, the rate of degradation can be significant, potentially leading to leaks or part failure.
    • The extent of degradation depends on the type of rubber, biodiesel composition, and exposure duration. Measurements have shown up to 10-15% increase in volume and softening in certain rubber types after prolonged exposure to high concentrations of biodiesel.
  2. Seals and Gaskets:
    • Fluoroelastomers and silicone-based materials show better resistance to biodiesel.
    • Older vehicles and equipment might require replacement of seals and gaskets with biodiesel-compatible materials when using high biodiesel blends.

Effects on Metal Components

  1. Corrosion:
    • Biodiesel can be more corrosive to certain metals compared to diesel, particularly copper, brass, lead, tin, and zinc.
    • Prolonged exposure to biodiesel, especially in high concentrations, can lead to increased corrosion rates.
    • Stainless steel, aluminum, and carbon steel demonstrate better resistance.
    • The acidity and moisture content of biodiesel play significant roles in corrosion. Measurements indicate that the corrosion rate can be up to 3 times higher with certain biodiesel blends compared to diesel.
  2. Fuel Injection System:
    • The high solvent nature of biodiesel can clean the fuel system, potentially dislodging accumulated residues and causing clogging in filters during initial transition.
    • Over time, biodiesel can lead to the deterioration of fuel injector seals and pump components, especially in older systems not designed for biodiesel use.

Long-term Effects on Engine Components

  1. Engine Wear:
    • Biodiesel has inherent lubricating properties that can reduce engine wear.
    • However, in high concentrations, the increased viscosity of biodiesel can affect the fuel injection process, potentially leading to incomplete combustion and increased engine deposits.
  2. Deposit Formation:
    • Biodiesel can contribute to the formation of deposits on fuel injectors, combustion chambers, and valves, especially in engines not optimized for biodiesel.
    • These deposits can affect engine performance and efficiency over time.
    • The degree of deposit formation varies with the type of biodiesel, engine design, and operating conditions.
  3. Oil Dilution:
    • Biodiesel can have a higher rate of dilution in engine oil, especially in engines with post-injection for particulate filter regeneration.
    • This dilution can affect the lubricating properties of the oil, necessitating more frequent oil changes.

The impact of biodiesel on fuel systems and engine components is a function of biodiesel concentration, material compatibility, and engine design. While biodiesel offers benefits like improved lubrication, its solvent properties and potential for increased corrosion and deposit formation require attention, especially in high concentration blends. Modern engines designed for biodiesel use are less susceptible to these issues, but older engines may require modifications and more frequent maintenance when using biodiesel, particularly above B20 blends.

Emission Profiles of Biodiesel Blends

The emission profiles of biodiesel blends differ significantly from those of pure diesel. These differences are attributable to the distinct chemical compositions of biodiesel and diesel. The key emissions to consider are greenhouse gases (GHGs), particulate matter (PM), and nitrogen oxides (NOx).

Greenhouse Gas Emissions

  1. Carbon Dioxide (CO2):
    • Biodiesel combustion typically results in lower net CO2 emissions compared to diesel.
    • This reduction is due to biodiesel’s lifecycle, where the carbon dioxide absorbed by the biomass during growth offsets the emissions from combustion.
    • B100 can reduce CO2 emissions by up to 78% compared to diesel, depending on feedstock and production methods.
    • For B20, the reduction in CO2 emissions is approximately 15-20%.
  2. Methane (CH4) and Nitrous Oxide (N2O):
    • Biodiesel blends have been shown to reduce CH4 and N2O emissions, both potent greenhouse gases.
    • Reduction rates can vary, but studies indicate decreases of up to 30% for methane and 10% for nitrous oxide with high biodiesel blends.

Particulate Matter (PM)

  1. Composition and Size:
    • Biodiesel emissions contain less PM than diesel emissions, and the particles tend to be of a smaller size and different chemical composition.
    • B20 can reduce PM emissions by 10-15%, while B100 can reduce it by up to 50%.
    • The PM from biodiesel is more likely to be organic carbon, whereas diesel PM is more likely to contain sulfates and aromatics.
  2. Health Implications:
    • The PM from biodiesel is considered less harmful due to lower levels of carcinogenic compounds.

Nitrogen Oxides (NOx)

  1. NOx Emissions:
    • Biodiesel can lead to a slight increase in NOx emissions, depending on engine type and operating conditions.
    • Increases of 1-10% have been observed, particularly with higher biodiesel concentrations like B100.
    • This increase is attributed to biodiesel’s higher cetane number and oxygen content, leading to higher combustion temperatures.
  2. Mitigation Strategies:
    • Engine tuning and after-treatment technologies like selective catalytic reduction (SCR) can mitigate NOx increases.

Biodiesel blends generally offer significant environmental benefits over pure diesel in terms of GHG and PM emissions. The increase in NOx emissions is a concern, but it can be managed with appropriate technologies. The choice of biodiesel blend level (e.g., B5, B20, B100) should balance the desired reductions in GHGs and PM against the potential increase in NOx emissions, engine compatibility, and other operational considerations.

Biodiesel in Cold Weather: Addressing the Gelling Issue

Cold Flow Properties of Biodiesel vs. Diesel

  1. Cloud Point (CP) and Pour Point (PP):
    • Biodiesel’s cold flow properties, including cloud point (CP) and pour point (PP), are critical in cold weather performance.
    • CP is the temperature at which wax crystals start to form, making the fuel look cloudy. PP is the temperature at which the fuel ceases to flow.
    • Biodiesel, particularly those made from animal fats or certain vegetable oils (like palm or soybean oil), typically has a higher CP and PP than regular diesel. For example, soy-based biodiesel can have a CP around 0°C to 4°C, whereas standard diesel’s CP is typically below -15°C.
    • The CP and PP for biodiesel can vary widely based on the feedstock, with some reaching as high as 15°C.
  2. Gel Point:
    • Biodiesel also has a higher gel point than diesel. This is the temperature at which the fuel gels and cannot be pumped.
    • For many biodiesel blends, the gel point can be only slightly lower than the CP, posing a risk in colder temperatures.

Solutions and Additives

  1. Cold Flow Improvers (CFIs):
    • CFIs are additives that prevent the formation of large wax crystals in biodiesel, lowering the CP and PP.
    • They work by modifying the size and shape of the wax crystals, ensuring they don’t interlock and gel.
    • The effectiveness of CFIs varies with biodiesel composition and the specific additive used.
  2. Blending with Winterized Diesel:
    • Blending biodiesel with specially formulated winter diesel, which has a much lower CP and PP, can improve cold weather performance.
    • Common blends in cold climates are B5 or B10, as lower biodiesel content significantly improves cold flow properties.
  3. Kerosene Blending:
    • Adding kerosene, which has very low CP and PP, to biodiesel can lower its gel point. A blend of 80% biodiesel and 20% kerosene can reduce the gel point significantly.
    • This solution, however, can reduce the lubricating properties of the biodiesel and may not be suitable for all engines.
  4. Fuel Heating Systems:
    • For extreme cold conditions, fuel heating systems can be used to maintain biodiesel at a temperature above its gel point.
    • This includes in-tank heaters, fuel-line heaters, and filter heaters.
  5. Storage and Handling:
    • Proper storage of biodiesel in a heated environment can prevent gelling.
    • Ensuring that fuel lines and tanks are insulated can also help maintain fuel temperatures above the gel point.

While biodiesel has inferior cold weather properties compared to diesel, the challenges of gelling can be managed through the use of additives, blending strategies, and mechanical solutions. The choice of solution often depends on the specific climate conditions, biodiesel blend level, and operational requirements of the vehicles or equipment in use.

Economic and Availability Considerations for Biodiesel

Regional Variations in Biodiesel Availability

  1. Production Capacity:
    • Biodiesel availability varies significantly by region, often correlating with local production capacity.
    • Major producers like the United States, Brazil, and parts of Europe have more readily available biodiesel supplies, often linked to their agricultural outputs (e.g., soybean in the U.S., sugarcane in Brazil).
  2. Distribution Networks:
    • Regions with well-established distribution networks for biodiesel, including blending facilities and transportation infrastructure, can offer more consistent and affordable supplies.
    • In contrast, areas lacking these networks may face higher prices and limited availability.
  3. Feedstock Availability:
    • The type of feedstock used for biodiesel production (e.g., rapeseed, palm oil, soybean, used cooking oil) varies regionally, affecting availability and cost.
    • Regions with abundant specific feedstocks can produce biodiesel more economically.

Cost Implications

  1. Price Comparison with Diesel:
    • Historically, biodiesel has been more expensive than diesel on a per-gallon basis, although this can fluctuate with market conditions.
    • For example, in the U.S., the average price difference between B100 and diesel can range from $0.20 to $1.00 per gallon, varying by location and market dynamics.
  2. Tax Incentives and Subsidies:
    • Many regions offer tax incentives or subsidies for biodiesel, impacting its final cost.
    • These incentives can make biodiesel blends competitively priced or even cheaper than regular diesel in some cases.
  3. Fuel Economy Considerations:
    • Biodiesel has a lower energy content per gallon than diesel (about 8-12% less for B100). This means vehicles running on biodiesel may require more fuel to travel the same distance, impacting overall fuel costs.
    • For B20, the reduction in fuel economy is usually around 2-3%, potentially offsetting cost savings from tax incentives.

Economic Feasibility for Different User Groups

  1. Commercial Fleets:
    • Fleets often benefit from economies of scale, making biodiesel more feasible, especially if they have access to bulk purchasing or are located near supply points.
    • Fleets operating in urban or regulated areas may also adopt biodiesel blends to meet emissions targets or regulatory requirements, despite the higher per-gallon cost.
  2. Individual Consumers:
    • For individual consumers, the decision to use biodiesel blends often depends on local pricing, availability, and personal commitment to reducing emissions.
    • The higher upfront cost of biodiesel can be a barrier, although some may find it justified by the environmental benefits.
  3. Agricultural and Industrial Users:
    • Users with access to biodiesel production (e.g., farmers producing oilseed crops) might find using biodiesel more economically feasible.
    • In industries where heavy machinery is used, the lubricating properties of biodiesel can also lead to longer engine life and reduced maintenance costs, contributing to long-term savings.

The economic viability of biodiesel varies widely based on regional factors like production capacity, feedstock availability, and government incentives, as well as the specific needs and scale of different user groups. While biodiesel typically incurs a higher cost per gallon compared to diesel, its environmental benefits, tax incentives, and potential long-term savings in engine maintenance can make it an attractive option for certain users, particularly large fleets and environmentally conscious consumers.

Regulatory and Quality Standards for Biodiesel Blending

International Quality Standards for Biodiesel

  1. ASTM D6751 (United States):
    • Establishes specifications for biodiesel (B100) for use as a blend component with diesel fuel.
    • Key parameters include:
      • Cetane number (minimum of 47)
      • Cloud point (varies by region)
      • Flash point (minimum of 93°C)
      • Sulfated ash content (maximum of 0.020% by mass)
      • Water and sediment content (maximum of 0.050% by volume)
    • These specifications ensure biodiesel’s compatibility with diesel engines and its performance, especially when blended.
  2. EN 14214 (European Union):
    • Similar to ASTM D6751 but with some differing specifications to suit European climate and engine technologies.
    • Important parameters include:
      • Cetane number (minimum of 51)
      • Density at 15°C (860-900 kg/m³)
      • Oxidation stability (minimum of 8 hours)
      • Ester content (minimum of 96.5% by mass)
    • EN 14214 places more emphasis on environmental aspects like oxidation stability, reflecting the EU’s focus on sustainability.

Regulatory Frameworks for Biodiesel Blending

  1. United States:
    • The Renewable Fuel Standard (RFS) program, established by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), mandates a certain volume of renewable fuel (including biodiesel) to be blended into transportation fuel.
    • The RFS sets annual targets for renewable fuel volumes, encouraging the use of biodiesel in transportation fuels.
    • Additionally, tax incentives and grants are available for biodiesel producers and users.
  2. European Union:
    • The Renewable Energy Directive (RED) sets mandates for the use of renewable energy, including biodiesel, in transportation.
    • Member states have specific targets for reducing greenhouse gas emissions from transport fuels, promoting biodiesel blending.
    • The EU also regulates the sustainability and carbon footprint of biofuels, including biodiesel.
  3. Other Regions:
    • Countries like Brazil, Argentina, and Indonesia have their own regulatory frameworks, often linked to their biodiesel production capacities and environmental policies.
    • Brazil, for instance, has progressively increased its mandatory biodiesel blend in diesel fuel, leveraging its large soybean production.

Impact of Standards and Regulations

  • These standards and regulations ensure that biodiesel meets certain quality benchmarks, making it safe and effective for use in engines.
  • They also promote the use of biodiesel, helping to reduce reliance on fossil fuels and decrease greenhouse gas emissions.
  • Compliance with these standards is crucial for biodiesel producers to access markets and for users to ensure engine compatibility and performance.

International standards like ASTM D6751 and EN 14214 play a crucial role in defining the quality of biodiesel, ensuring its suitability for use in various climates and engines. Regulatory frameworks like the RFS in the US and the RED in the EU not only dictate the blend levels but also ensure that biodiesel contributes to broader environmental and sustainability goals.

Conclusion

Mixing biodiesel with regular diesel is not only feasible but also increasingly common in various sectors. The compatibility of biodiesel with diesel, across different blend ratios, offers a versatile approach to fuel usage, catering to both environmental concerns and energy demands.

While lower blends like B5 and B20 generally have minimal impact on engine performance and are suitable for most diesel engines, higher blends or pure biodiesel (B100) may necessitate engine modifications and more rigorous maintenance protocols. The benefits of reduced emissions and improved lubrication properties with biodiesel are counterbalanced by considerations such as colder climate performance and material compatibility in the fuel system.

Ultimately, the decision to use biodiesel blends depends on balancing these technical aspects with economic, environmental, and regulatory factors, ensuring that the integration of biodiesel into our fuel systems is both efficient and sustainable.

Scroll to Top